Cyber Insurance for SMEs: What Insurers Now Expect You to Have in Place

Cyber Insurance for SMEs

Quick answer

Most UK cyber insurers now expect a set of basic security controls. The big ones are MFA, regular patching, secure backups and endpoint protection. Staff training and an incident response plan are also common asks. If you say a control is in place and it is not, a claim may be refused.

Why insurers are asking harder questions

Cyber claims have grown fast. Ransomware and email fraud are the main drivers.

Insurers have responded. They now check your security before they offer cover.

A few years ago, the proposal form was a few tick boxes. Today it can run to several pages.

Weak answers can mean higher premiums, lower limits or no cover at all.

The good news? Most of what insurers want is basic good practice. It protects you whether you claim or not.

What security controls do cyber insurers expect?

Every insurer is different. But these controls appear on almost every proposal form.

ControlWhat insurers usually askWhy it matters
Multi-factor authentication (MFA)Is MFA on email, remote access and admin accounts?Stops most attacks that use stolen passwords.
PatchingDo you install security updates quickly?Attackers target known flaws in old software.
BackupsAre backups separate, protected and tested?Lets you recover without paying a ransom.
Endpoint protectionDo all devices have modern antivirus or EDR?Spots and blocks malware on laptops and servers.
Email securityDo you filter spam and block spoofed emails?Phishing is the most common way in.
Staff trainingDo staff get regular phishing awareness training?People are the last line of defence.
Admin rightsAre admin accounts limited and separate?Limits damage if one account is hacked.
Incident response planDo you have a written plan for an attack?Speeds up response and cuts losses.
Supported softwareDo you still use end-of-life systems?Unsupported systems get no security fixes.

Is MFA required for cyber insurance?

For many insurers, yes. MFA is now one of the most common must-haves.

They usually want it on:

  • Email, such as Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace.
  • Remote access, such as VPNs and remote desktop.
  • Admin and privileged accounts.
  • Cloud and finance systems.

Without MFA, some insurers will decline cover. Others may limit what they pay for ransomware.

MFA is cheap and quick to set up. It is one of the best-value fixes you can make.

What do insurers want to know about your backups?

Backups are your safety net. Insurers want proof they will work.

Expect questions like these:

  • How often do your backups run?
  • Is at least one copy offline or immutable?
  • Are backups kept separate from your main network?
  • When did you last test a full restore?
  • Is MFA on your backup system?

Ransomware often tries to delete backups first. A protected copy is what saves you.

Not sure your backups are up to it? See our data backup and recovery service.

Does Cyber Essentials help with cyber insurance?

It can help a lot.

Cyber Essentials is a UK Government-backed scheme. It covers five core controls: firewalls, secure settings, user access, malware protection and patching.

Many insurers see certification as a good sign. It shows you have the basics in place.

IASME has offered free cyber liability cover to some qualifying small UK organisations that certify. Check the current terms, as eligibility rules apply.

Cyber Essentials Plus goes further. An assessor tests your systems in person or remotely.

Why do cyber insurance claims get refused?

Most refused claims come down to a few common problems.

1. The proposal form was wrong

You said MFA was on everywhere. In fact, one account was missed. If that is how the attacker got in, your claim could be at risk.

2. Controls were not kept up

Backups stopped running months ago. Or patches were skipped. Your policy may need controls to stay in place.

3. You reported it too late

Many policies need quick notice. Waiting days can cause problems.

4. You did not use the insurer’s panel

Some policies need you to use their chosen response team.

5. The loss is not covered

Some policies exclude certain types of fraud or old, unsupported systems.

The fix: answer the proposal form with your IT provider. Then keep the controls running and keep evidence that they work.

What does cyber insurance usually cover?

Policies vary. But most fall into two parts.

First-party cover (your losses)Third-party cover (claims against you)
Incident response and IT forensicsLegal costs if clients sue you
Data and system restorationLiability for data breaches
Business interruption and lost incomeRegulatory investigation costs, where insurable
Ransomware negotiation supportMedia and reputation claims
Crisis PR and customer notificationBreach of contract claims linked to a cyber event

Read the wording closely. Check limits, excesses and exclusions with your broker.

How to get insurance-ready: a simple checklist

DoneAction
☐Turn on MFA for email, remote access and admin accounts
☐Install security updates within 14 days
☐Set up offline or immutable backups and test a restore
☐Put modern endpoint protection on every device
☐Run phishing awareness training for all staff
☐Remove or replace unsupported software
☐Write a one-page incident response plan
☐Consider Cyber Essentials certification
☐Keep records that prove each control is working

Get insurance-ready with Digit-IT

Digit-IT helps small businesses across Hertfordshire and North London meet insurer requirements.

We check your controls, fix the gaps and help you answer proposal forms accurately. We also keep everything running, so your cover stays valid.

Call 0333 577 7004 or visit our cyber security services page.

Frequently asked questions

What do I need to get cyber insurance as a small business?

Most insurers expect MFA, regular patching, secure tested backups, endpoint protection and staff training. Many also ask about admin rights and an incident response plan.

Can you get cyber insurance without MFA?

It is getting harder. Many insurers now require MFA on email, remote access and admin accounts. Without it, you may face refusal, higher premiums or reduced cover.

Why would a cyber insurance claim be rejected?

Common reasons include wrong answers on the proposal form, controls that lapsed, late reporting, or a loss the policy excludes.

Does Cyber Essentials lower cyber insurance premiums?

It can help. Certification shows insurers you have the basics in place. Some qualifying small UK firms have also received free cyber liability cover with certification.

Is cyber insurance a replacement for cyber security?

No. Insurance helps you recover costs after an attack. Good security stops many attacks happening in the first place. You need both.

Leave A Comment

Cart